For centuries, cedar shake roofing has been admired for its rustic charm, durability, and timeless appeal. Its textured beauty lends an organic elegance to homes, making it a top choice for homeowners seeking to boost curb appeal. Over time, natural cedar shake weathers into a unique silvery-gray patina, adding to its classic character and further enhancing its reputation as a premium roofing material. But while natural cedar has long held the crown, modern advancements in roofing have introduced a formidable contender: synthetic cedar shake.
Synthetic cedar shakes, engineered from advanced polymers or recycled materials, offer homeowners an alternative that replicates cedar in its natural splendor while boasting enhanced durability, longevity, and reduced maintenance requirements. With innovations in design, these synthetic options have sparked a growing debate among homeowners and industry experts alike. Is it worth sticking to the traditional, natural cedar shakes, or do synthetic versions offer the superior solution for today’s homes?
In this in-depth guide, we will explore the key differences between natural and synthetic cedar shake roofing. From durability to maintenance and cost considerations, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each option to help you make an informed decision. Whether you’re drawn to the authentic charm of natural cedar or the modern resilience of synthetic alternatives, understanding these factors will equip you with the knowledge to choose the right roof for your home.
The Timeless Beauty and Durability of Natural Cedar Shake Roofing
Natural cedar shake roofing has been a beloved choice for centuries, known for its unmatched combination of beauty, durability, and natural resistance to the elements. Sourced primarily from the Pacific Northwest and Canada, cedar shakes are crafted from high-quality cedar wood, with Western Red Cedar standing out as a top choice. Its ability to resist moisture, decay, and insect damage makes it an ideal roofing material, even in areas prone to extreme weather. This wood, rich in natural oils, offers protection against the elements without the need for chemical treatments, allowing homeowners to enjoy the natural aesthetic and longevity of the material.
One of the most remarkable qualities of natural cedar is its ability to enhance the aesthetic appeal of a home. Cedar shakes age gracefully, developing a beautiful patina over time, transitioning from warm, rich reddish-brown hues to an elegant silvery-gray tone. This aging process lends the home a unique character, increasing curb appeal and blending harmoniously with both traditional and contemporary architectural styles. Homeowners have the flexibility to choose between two distinct styles: hand-split shakes, which offer a rugged, organic texture ideal for rustic or traditional homes, and tapersawn shakes, which provide a more refined, uniform appearance suited for modern or transitional designs.
Grades of Natural Cedar Shakes
When selecting cedar shakes, it’s essential to understand the different grades available, as these affect the price, durability, and aesthetic qualities of the roof. Cedar shakes are typically graded based on the quality of the wood grain:
- Economy Grade (Common Grade): This entry-level grade is the most affordable option, featuring more natural imperfections in the wood, such as knots and uneven grain patterns. While budget-friendly, economy-grade shakes tend to have a shorter lifespan and require more frequent maintenance, making them a better fit for homeowners willing to balance costs with upkeep.
- Select Grade (80/20 Split): A middle-ground option, select-grade shakes offer a good balance between cost and quality. Around 80% of the shakes feature straight grain, which increases their durability and overall aesthetic appeal. Select-grade shakes are ideal for homeowners seeking a longer-lasting and more attractive roof without the higher cost associated with premium options.
- 100% Straight Grain: This premium-grade cedar shake is cut from the heartwood of the cedar tree, ensuring the wood grain is straight and uniform. These shakes offer superior durability, longevity, and aesthetic appeal, but they come with a higher price tag. However, the investment is often worthwhile for homeowners who want a roof that will age beautifully, require less maintenance, and last for decades.
Over time, natural cedar shake roofing develops a distinctive patina, which many homeowners find appealing. This graceful aging process adds character to the roof, ensuring that no two homes look exactly alike, which is part of the allure of natural cedar.
Uncovering the Advantages of Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing
While natural cedar shakes offer undeniable beauty, they do come with the need for regular maintenance to prevent issues like warping, rotting, and insect infestations. For homeowners who love the look of cedar but prefer a low-maintenance option, synthetic cedar shake roofing provides a modern alternative.
Synthetic cedar shakes are typically crafted from high-performance materials like engineered polymers or recycled composites. These materials are designed to replicate the appearance and texture of natural cedar, mimicking the intricate grain patterns and rough edges that make natural shakes so attractive. Due to innovations in manufacturing, synthetic shakes now offer a highly realistic alternative that is almost indistinguishable from natural cedar.
The primary advantage of synthetic cedar shakes lies in their enhanced durability. Unlike natural wood, synthetic shakes are not prone to splitting, rotting, or fading. They are designed to endure severe weather conditions, such as heavy rain, snow, and strong winds, while maintaining both their structural integrity and visual appeal.This makes them an excellent choice for homeowners seeking the beauty of cedar without the ongoing need for maintenance and treatment.
A key advantage of synthetic cedar shake roofing is its remarkable color retention. Unlike natural cedar, which can fade over time, synthetic shakes are specifically designed to maintain their original hue—whether you favor the rich tones of freshly cut cedar or the charming patina of aged wood. This means your roof will remain beautiful for decades with minimal maintenance.
Natural vs. Synthetic Cedar Shake Roofing: A Comprehensive Guide
When deciding between natural and synthetic cedar shake roofing, it’s essential to consider several critical factors, including lifespan, durability, maintenance, warranties, and overall cost. Both materials offer unique benefits, but your final decision will depend on your specific needs, budget, and long-term maintenance expectations. Below is a detailed comparison to help guide you through the decision-making process.
Lifespan
Natural Cedar Shakes:
With proper care and regular maintenance, natural cedar shake roofs can last between 30 to 40 years. In regions with mild climates—such as areas with lower humidity and minimal exposure to pests or harsh weather conditions—natural cedar shakes may even surpass their typical lifespan. However, ensuring this longevity requires consistent treatments, inspections, and protective measures against common issues like moisture damage, moss growth, and insect infestations.
Synthetic Cedar Shakes:
Engineered to endure harsh environmental conditions, synthetic cedar shakes often carry warranties of 50 years or more. These materials are naturally resistant to factors that typically shorten the lifespan of natural wood, including moisture, UV rays, and pests. As a result, synthetic shakes not only last longer but also demand significantly less maintenance, making them a durable and hassle-free choice.
Durability
Natural Cedar Shakes:
Natural cedar shakes, while strong, are more susceptible to environmental damage. Moisture, for instance, can lead to issues like rot and mold, especially in damp climates. Prolonged exposure to UV rays can cause the shakes to dry out and become brittle, increasing the risk of cracking and splitting. Moreover, cedar is prone to insect damage if not properly treated. Over time, natural shakes may warp or curl, particularly if regular maintenance is neglected.
Synthetic Cedar Shakes:
Designed to mimic the look of real cedar, synthetic shakes are created from advanced materials that resist many of the issues that plague natural wood. Synthetic shakes are impervious to rot, insects, and moisture, making them ideal for regions prone to extreme weather conditions. They don’t warp, crack, or curl, ensuring that they retain their appearance and functionality for many decades. This enhanced durability makes synthetic cedar a reliable choice for homeowners looking for a long-lasting roofing option.
Maintenance
Natural Cedar Shakes:
To keep natural cedar shake roofs in optimal condition, regular maintenance is essential. Homeowners must invest in periodic treatments to protect the wood from moisture, UV damage, and pests. Additionally, regular cleaning is required to remove moss, algae, and other organic matter that may accumulate on the surface. Failure to perform these tasks can shorten the roof’s lifespan and lead to costly repairs.
Synthetic Cedar Shakes:
One of the standout benefits of synthetic cedar shakes is their low-maintenance nature. Synthetic shakes require little to no maintenance over their lifespan, with no need for treatments, cleaning, or routine inspections. This makes them a hassle-free option for homeowners who prefer not to worry about frequent upkeep or potential damage. The ease of maintenance combined with long-lasting durability adds to the appeal of synthetic roofing.
Warranties
Natural Cedar Shakes:
Typically, natural cedar shakes come with limited warranties, often focusing more on the installation rather than the materials themselves. While many contractors offer installation warranties, the performance of the roof is largely dependent on how well it is maintained over time. This means that natural cedar shake roofs do not typically come with the same comprehensive manufacturer warranties that synthetic materials offer.
Synthetic Cedar Shakes:
In contrast, synthetic cedar shakes often come with extensive manufacturer warranties, which can extend up to 50 years. These warranties typically cover a range of potential defects and performance issues, offering homeowners a greater sense of security. The robust warranties provided with synthetic shakes ensure that the roof will perform as expected for decades, without the need for extensive maintenance or repairs.
Cost
Natural Cedar Shakes:
As a premium roofing material, natural cedar shakes come at a higher price point, ranging from $25.00 to $30.00 per square foot. This cost includes the price of high-quality wood and the expertise required for proper installation. Additionally, natural cedar shakes come with the added expense of ongoing maintenance, treatments, and repairs, which can add up over the roof’s lifespan.
Synthetic Cedar Shakes:
While synthetic cedar shakes are still considered a high-end roofing material, they are generally more affordable than their natural counterparts, with prices ranging from $14.00 to $18.00 per square foot. The reduced need for maintenance, combined with their longer lifespan, makes synthetic shakes a more cost-effective option in the long term. Homeowners can expect lower overall expenses with synthetic shakes due to fewer repairs and lower maintenance costs.
Which Option is Best for Your Home?
Both natural and synthetic cedar shake roofs provide unique benefits, making them exceptional options for enhancing your home’s beauty and value. The decision between the two depends largely on your personal preferences, your budget, and how much time you are willing to spend on maintenance.
- Natural Cedar Shakes provide a classic, organic look that ages gracefully and offers a timeless appeal. However, this option is best suited for homeowners who are willing to commit to regular upkeep and repairs to ensure their roof lasts.
- Synthetic Cedar Shakes deliver the same charming aesthetic with the added benefit of superior durability and minimal maintenance. For those seeking a long-term solution that requires little upkeep, synthetic cedar shakes represent an excellent investment that balances appearance, performance, and cost.
Conclusion
When deciding between natural and synthetic cedar shake roofing, it’s crucial to consider what matters most to you in terms of aesthetics, maintenance, and long-term investment. Natural cedar shakes offer unmatched beauty, bringing a rustic, timeless appeal to any home. Their organic texture and unique aging process make them a favorite for homeowners who appreciate the authenticity of real wood. However, natural cedar requires ongoing care, including periodic treatments to prevent rot, insects, and weather damage. If you’re willing to invest in routine maintenance to preserve the roof’s charm, natural cedar shakes could be an excellent option for your home.
On the other hand, synthetic cedar shakes have become an increasingly popular alternative, providing the look of real cedar with far less upkeep. Made from materials like rubber or plastic composites, synthetic shakes are designed to withstand the elements, resist decay, and last for decades without the need for frequent repairs or treatments. They can also be more cost-effective over time due to their longevity and lower maintenance demands. For homeowners who prioritize convenience and durability, synthetic cedar shakes represent a wise investment that maintains aesthetic appeal without compromise.
Both natural and synthetic cedar shakes offer distinct advantages in terms of beauty and can significantly enhance your home’s value. However, synthetic shakes provide additional advantages in durability, weather resistance, and cost savings, making them a popular choice among modern homeowners seeking long-lasting roofing solutions.
Before you make a final decision, it’s always best to consult with a professional roofer who has experience installing both types of cedar shakes. A roofing expert can assess the unique requirements of your home, including climate, architectural style, and budget, and help you determine which roofing material aligns best with your needs and lifestyle.
At Last Frontier Roofing and Construction, we are specialists in both natural and synthetic cedar shake installations. Whether you’re captivated by the natural warmth of real cedar or prefer the low-maintenance durability of synthetic alternatives, our team is here to guide you through the selection process. We’ll help you make an informed decision and ensure that your roof is installed to the highest standards, providing beauty, protection, and value for years to come. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and discover which cedar shake roofing option is the best fit for your home!
3 Comments